Skip to main content

Applied Forensic Walkthroughs

Fraud Investigation Case Studies for CFE Prep.

Study original end-to-end forensic scenarios covering shell-vendor billing, quarter-end channel stuffing, ghost-employee payroll, and accounts receivable lapping—complete with red flags, investigative sequences, and preventive controls.

Forensic Scenario Library (4)

Filter walkthroughs by FinCertPrep internal study category.

Isometric geometric illustration of layered procurement audit ledgers and forensic variance bars
Case 01Procurement & Billing FraudShell-Vendor Kickback Scheme

Tracing a Shell-Vendor Billing Scheme Through Procurement Ledger Analysis

An industrial distributor noticed consulting expenses in one regional logistics division rising 42% year-over-year despite flat warehouse volume. No single invoice exceeded the $10,000 vice-president sign-off threshold, allowing payments to clear routine accounts payable workflows for fourteen months.

Related FinCertPrep Category: Investigation & EvidencePractice Investigation & Evidence Questions

Key Red Flags

  • Three consulting vendors submitted invoices spaced 7–10 days apart for amounts consistently between $9,400 and $9,950.
  • All three vendors used the same virtual office address and lacked verifiable corporate websites or third-party references.
  • ERP audit logs revealed the regional procurement lead personally submitted all three vendor onboarding packets on Friday evenings.

Investigative Steps

  1. Extracted 24 months of AP disbursement data and ran threshold-clustering and duplicate-attribute queries (address, phone, bank account, tax ID).
  2. Preserved ERP vendor master modification logs, email archive records, and digital approval timestamps prior to any employee interviews.
  3. Cross-referenced corporate registry filings to identify a common registered agent linked to a relative of the procurement lead.
  4. Interviewed accounts payable clerks and receiving supervisors first to confirm zero physical or documented consulting deliverables existed.

Preventive Controls

  • Separate vendor master-file creation and verification from purchasing approval authority.
  • Implement automated continuous monitoring for split invoicing just below approval thresholds and shared vendor/employee attributes.
  • Require independent verification of service deliverables before releasing disbursements for non-inventory consulting contracts.
Geometric network diagram showing interconnected financial ledger nodes and settlement flows
Case 02Financial Statement FraudPremature Revenue Recognition

Uncovering Quarter-End Channel Stuffing & Undisclosed Return Side Letters

A mid-market hardware manufacturer beat Q4 revenue forecasts by 11% during an industry slowdown, triggering executive performance bonuses. In late January, finance analysts noticed an unusual surge in product returns and aged receivables from two major regional distributors.

Related FinCertPrep Category: Transactions & SchemesPractice Transactions & Schemes Questions

Key Red Flags

  • Nearly 38% of Q4 revenue was booked in the final five business days of December.
  • Days Sales Outstanding (DSO) jumped sharply while operating cash flow lagged reported net income.
  • Post-close credit memos in January and February reversed more than half of the December distributor shipments.

Investigative Steps

  1. Performed cutoff analysis comparing bill-of-lading dates, carrier pickup timestamps, and invoice posting dates.
  2. Reconciled January credit memos back to specific December sales orders and sales-representative IDs.
  3. Reviewed preserved sales correspondence and distributor confirmations, uncovering signed side letters granting unrestricted 90-day return privileges.

Preventive Controls

  • Require independent finance review of non-standard contract terms, extended payment schedules, and unusual period-end shipment volume.
  • Monitor post-period credit memos and sales returns against prior-quarter revenue spikes as a recurring detective control.
  • Align executive incentive structures with collected cash flows and multi-period quality metrics rather than short-term top-line spikes.
Geometric compliance shield illustration representing structured payroll control validation
Case 03Asset MisappropriationPayroll Ghost-Employee Scheme

Detecting Ghost Employees & Timecard Overrides Across Multi-Site Payroll

A multi-location hospitality group experienced high seasonal turnover, giving branch payroll coordinators broad latitude to add temporary workers quickly. An internal audit of labor-cost variances flagged one location consistently running 9% over comparable sites.

Related FinCertPrep Category: Investigation & EvidencePractice Investigation & Evidence Questions

Key Red Flags

  • Four seasonal employee records showed continuous biweekly payouts across off-peak months with identical 40-hour entries.
  • Payroll records contained no completed tax withholding elections, emergency contacts, or badge-swipe logs.
  • Two of the four records routed direct deposits to the exact same bank account number.

Investigative Steps

  1. Reconciled the payroll disbursement file independently against the HR master roster and physical access/scheduling logs.
  2. Ran duplicate-bank-account and duplicate-address matching across both active employees and payroll coordinators.
  3. Secured payroll system change logs proving the local coordinator reactivated terminated IDs and manually entered hours without supervisor sign-off.

Preventive Controls

  • Restrict payroll setup strictly to HR personnel independent of payroll processing and check/ACH distribution.
  • Automate exception reports flagging duplicate bank accounts, missing HR onboarding fields, and employees with zero access-log activity.
  • Require periodic physical or independent supervisor verification of active headcount at decentralized sites.
Geometric financial settlement diagram illustrating rolling accounts receivable posting lags
Case 04Cash & Receivables FraudAccounts Receivable Lapping

Exposing Accounts Receivable Lapping in Regional Customer Billing

A regional medical-supply distributor noticed rising customer complaints about past-due notices for invoices customers insisted they had already paid weeks earlier. The single AR specialist who opened incoming mail, posted customer remittances, and prepared daily bank deposits had not taken a full week off in three years.

Related FinCertPrep Category: Prevention & DeterrencePractice Prevention & Deterrence Questions

Key Red Flags

  • Repeated customer inquiries reporting unapplied check payments despite cleared check copies.
  • Systematic 5-to-12-day delays between check deposit dates and customer sub-ledger credit postings.
  • Unusual partial-payment adjustments and unauthorized small write-offs concentrated in one clerk’s user ID.

Investigative Steps

  1. Assigned an independent staff member to cover AR posting during a mandatory vacation rotation, causing customer aging discrepancies to surface immediately.
  2. Compared bank-validated deposit slips (remitter names and check amounts) line by line against daily AR cash-application batches.
  3. Preserved lockbox and ERP adjustment logs documenting rolling payment misapplications across 19 customer accounts.

Preventive Controls

  • Route customer check remittances through a bank lockbox or separate mail-opening custody from AR ledger posting.
  • Enforce independent review of all credit memos, bad-debt write-offs, and customer dispute inquiries.
  • Pair segregation of duties with mandatory job rotation or uninterrupted annual vacation policies for cash-handling roles.