Tracing a Shell-Vendor Billing Scheme Through Procurement Ledger Analysis
An industrial distributor noticed consulting expenses in one regional logistics division rising 42% year-over-year despite flat warehouse volume. No single invoice exceeded the $10,000 vice-president sign-off threshold, allowing payments to clear routine accounts payable workflows for fourteen months.
Key Red Flags
- Three consulting vendors submitted invoices spaced 7–10 days apart for amounts consistently between $9,400 and $9,950.
- All three vendors used the same virtual office address and lacked verifiable corporate websites or third-party references.
- ERP audit logs revealed the regional procurement lead personally submitted all three vendor onboarding packets on Friday evenings.
Investigative Steps
- Extracted 24 months of AP disbursement data and ran threshold-clustering and duplicate-attribute queries (address, phone, bank account, tax ID).
- Preserved ERP vendor master modification logs, email archive records, and digital approval timestamps prior to any employee interviews.
- Cross-referenced corporate registry filings to identify a common registered agent linked to a relative of the procurement lead.
- Interviewed accounts payable clerks and receiving supervisors first to confirm zero physical or documented consulting deliverables existed.
Preventive Controls
- Separate vendor master-file creation and verification from purchasing approval authority.
- Implement automated continuous monitoring for split invoicing just below approval thresholds and shared vendor/employee attributes.
- Require independent verification of service deliverables before releasing disbursements for non-inventory consulting contracts.